{"schema":"https://automatedassays.local/schemas/real-data-evidence-bundle/1.0.0","schema_version":"1.0.0","bundle_public_id":"33083627-654f-4fcd-8601-7ff39e9834c0","generated_at":"2026-11-03T17:45:07.000000Z","mode":"real_data","label":"Pathway analysis (GO, KEGG, fry, camera)","record":{"record_id":"pmid:27508061","science_record_content_hash":null,"science_record_source":null},"operation":{"name":"rna_seq_pathway_enrichment","version":"0.1.0","parameters":{"paper":"pmid:27508061","paper_version":"2","stage":"pathway_enrichment","source_files":{"targets.txt":"sha256:88ae42c0539403073f0bbbd53287dd9c9cf61ddd5b1a42856243d7d99113cb8b","edgeRQL.R":"sha256:3b11478ac314c4456af8b4ba7af7992e938488ffc7bec88d3f73f42aed4c0bba","edgeRQL.Rnw":"sha256:defd3acb73dcbfe885ca02209ac9437b785b4ccf12c7ba09a8a8bb311173902d"},"software":{"edgeR":"3.14.0","limma":"3.28.21","org.Mm.eg.db":"3.3.0","GO.db":"3.3.0","gplots":"3.0.1"},"deviations":{"kegg_transport":"KEGG's REST endpoint now redirects http to https, and the pinned R's url() reader cannot follow a redirect, so the gene-to-pathway table kegga reads is fetched over https and passed to limma::kegga as the gene.pathway and pathway.names arguments that limma documents for supplying those tables directly. The species argument, the gene sets and the analysis are the authors' own.","r_patch_release":"The paper ran on R 3.3.1 and this platform runs on R 3.3.2.","limma_patch_release":"The paper ran on limma 3.28.6 and this platform runs on limma 3.28.21, the last patch of the same Bioconductor 3.3 series.","annotation_dbi_patch_release":"The paper ran on AnnotationDbi 1.34.3 and this platform runs on AnnotationDbi 1.38.0, the last patch of the same Bioconductor 3.3 series.","operating_system":"The paper ran on Windows 7 x64 and this platform runs on Linux."}}},"dataset":{"asset_id":"GEO:GSE60450:Lactation-GenewiseCounts","source_url":"https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/query/acc.cgi?acc=GSE60450","licence":{"state":"open"}},"result":{"stage":"pathway_enrichment","label":"Pathway analysis (GO, KEGG, fry, camera)","status":"complete","numbers":{"stage":"pathway_enrichment","go":{"method":"goana (edgeR) on the glmTreat result","species":"Mm","top_terms":[{"term":"GO:0022402","ontology":"BP","size":931,"up":19,"down":118,"p_up":0.9133209069,"p_down":2.692287877e-23},{"term":"GO:0000280","ontology":"BP","size":460,"up":10,"down":78,"p_up":0.7889078421,"p_down":3.579961074e-23},{"term":"GO:1903047","ontology":"BP","size":628,"up":8,"down":92,"p_up":0.9949406353,"p_down":1.561572573e-22},{"term":"GO:0048285","ontology":"BP","size":500,"up":11,"down":78,"p_up":0.7849824518,"p_down":7.348993877e-21},{"term":"GO:0007067","ontology":"BP","size":376,"up":4,"down":66,"p_up":0.9912410921,"p_down":1.506310882e-20},{"term":"GO:0007049","ontology":"BP","size":1301,"up":21,"down":138,"p_up":0.9967994777,"p_down":6.215728554e-20},{"term":"GO:0000278","ontology":"BP","size":736,"up":8,"down":96,"p_up":0.9992973552,"p_down":7.967298906e-20},{"term":"GO:0007059","ontology":"BP","size":237,"up":1,"down":49,"p_up":0.9984426714,"p_down":1.497257889e-18},{"term":"GO:0051301","ontology":"BP","size":550,"up":6,"down":77,"p_up":0.9972116531,"p_down":8.954040553e-18},{"term":"GO:0000776","ontology":"CC","size":112,"up":1,"down":33,"p_up":0.9522513239,"p_down":8.989873899e-18},{"term":"GO:0000775","ontology":"CC","size":163,"up":1,"down":38,"p_up":0.9881422253,"p_down":1.768810727e-16},{"term":"GO:0098813","ontology":"BP","size":171,"up":1,"down":38,"p_up":0.9904739593,"p_down":9.644442717e-16},{"term":"GO:0042254","ontology":"BP","size":223,"up":1,"down":42,"p_up":0.9977116399,"p_down":1.433142715e-14},{"term":"GO:0098687","ontology":"CC","size":278,"up":6,"down":47,"p_up":0.7560015933,"p_down":2.688979822e-14},{"term":"GO:0005730","ontology":"CC","size":663,"up":4,"down":78,"p_up":0.9999857439,"p_down":9.719474581e-14}]},"kegg":{"method":"kegga (limma) on the glmTreat result, with the KEGG link table read over https","species":"Mm","deviation":"KEGG's REST endpoint now redirects http to https and the pinned R cannot follow that redirect, so the gene-to-pathway table kegga reads is fetched over https and passed as limma's gene.pathway argument. KEGG's content is versioned by the day, so this stage cannot reproduce the May 2016 published numbers.","top_terms":[{"pathway":"mmu04110","size":153,"up":1,"down":29,"p_up":0.591836515,"p_down":3.016301622e-27},{"pathway":"mmu03008","size":75,"up":0,"down":19,"p_up":1,"p_down":7.666597975e-21},{"pathway":"mmu01100","size":1330,"up":37,"down":57,"p_up":1.750292706e-15,"p_down":2.020355469e-18},{"pathway":"mmu04382","size":138,"up":13,"down":10,"p_up":1.803710868e-12,"p_down":3.610453469e-6},{"pathway":"mmu05150","size":47,"up":3,"down":11,"p_up":0.002611445354,"p_down":3.3938957e-12},{"pathway":"mmu05200","size":453,"up":11,"down":26,"p_up":7.658383128e-5,"p_down":1.202759745e-11},{"pathway":"mmu05166","size":214,"up":4,"down":18,"p_up":0.03692061608,"p_down":4.105916087e-11},{"pathway":"mmu05171","size":216,"up":4,"down":18,"p_up":0.03799544864,"p_down":4.791112757e-11},{"pathway":"mmu01232","size":76,"up":1,"down":12,"p_up":0.3588942391,"p_down":4.925622091e-11},{"pathway":"mmu04514","size":120,"up":2,"down":14,"p_up":0.154958117,"p_down":8.018907688e-11},{"pathway":"mmu04510","size":190,"up":13,"down":9,"p_up":1.043935465e-10,"p_down":0.0002986874179},{"pathway":"mmu04820","size":196,"up":13,"down":13,"p_up":1.537390259e-10,"p_down":3.502924311e-7},{"pathway":"mmu04972","size":69,"up":9,"down":4,"p_up":2.65411064e-10,"p_down":0.007402066459},{"pathway":"mmu04081","size":135,"up":11,"down":8,"p_up":4.621476803e-10,"p_down":0.0001417491619},{"pathway":"mmu04640","size":60,"up":2,"down":10,"p_up":0.04792712899,"p_down":1.18538522e-9}]},"fry":{"method":"fry (edgeR) with the GO gene sets the authors selected","gene_sets":["GO:0032465","GO:0000281","GO:0000920"],"terms":["GO:0032465","GO:0000920","GO:0000281"],"n_genes":[48,16,30],"directions":["Up","Down","Up"],"p_values":[0.0004642488159,0.001902458392,0.007277059742],"fdr":[0.001392746448,0.002853687588,0.007277059742]},"camera":{"method":"camera (limma) over the MSigDB mouse C2 v5p1 collection the authors used","contrast":"B.virgin - L.virgin","inter_gene_cor":0.01,"sets":[{"name":"LIM_MAMMARY_STEM_CELL_UP","size":782,"direction":"Up","p_value":1.979058404e-43,"fdr":9.349071903e-40},{"name":"LIM_MAMMARY_LUMINAL_MATURE_DN","size":169,"direction":"Up","p_value":3.747197775e-25,"fdr":8.850881144e-22},{"name":"SASAI_RESISTANCE_TO_NEOPLASTIC_TRANSFROMATION","size":80,"direction":"Up","p_value":4.077800151e-20,"fdr":6.421175971e-17},{"name":"LIM_MAMMARY_STEM_CELL_DN","size":664,"direction":"Down","p_value":2.245244599e-19,"fdr":2.651633871e-16},{"name":"FARMER_BREAST_CANCER_CLUSTER_4","size":74,"direction":"Up","p_value":2.92108931e-19,"fdr":2.75984518e-16},{"name":"NABA_BASEMENT_MEMBRANES","size":52,"direction":"Up","p_value":1.573422588e-17,"fdr":1.238808051e-14},{"name":"HAEGERSTRAND_RESPONSE_TO_IMATINIB","size":35,"direction":"Up","p_value":3.973744811e-17,"fdr":2.681710069e-14},{"name":"ROZANOV_MMP14_TARGETS_SUBSET","size":83,"direction":"Up","p_value":5.164662658e-16,"fdr":3.0497333e-13},{"name":"REACTOME_COLLAGEN_FORMATION","size":70,"direction":"Up","p_value":1.2967718e-15,"fdr":6.806611093e-13},{"name":"REACTOME_NCAM1_INTERACTIONS","size":71,"direction":"Up","p_value":2.169966335e-15,"fdr":1.025092096e-12},{"name":"OXFORD_RALB_TARGETS_UP","size":27,"direction":"Up","p_value":4.537966308e-15,"fdr":1.948850258e-12},{"name":"ANASTASSIOU_CANCER_MESENCHYMAL_TRANSITION_SIGNATURE","size":148,"direction":"Up","p_value":7.064363607e-15,"fdr":2.781004473e-12},{"name":"PAPASPYRIDONOS_UNSTABLE_ATEROSCLEROTIC_PLAQUE_DN","size":68,"direction":"Up","p_value":1.346368295e-14,"fdr":4.892495252e-12},{"name":"LIM_MAMMARY_LUMINAL_PROGENITOR_UP","size":92,"direction":"Down","p_value":2.005252528e-14,"fdr":6.766294958e-12}]}},"artefact_sha256":{"go_terms.tsv":"sha256:e0698040c06a83c48cceacf741abf10d1d19afd5b0160b2aab5dad7dd57847d9","kegg_terms.tsv":"sha256:ba9ac502e01c1e0361b313c45d9dc02e63b0377adc1eb2adb0bfc9e452cb18ae","fry.tsv":"sha256:4db1fc47ef24b783ff698fe87c7abdbb74cae4e90a65d3453422fdca229e4bd8","camera.tsv":"sha256:116eccfac5fc6498b8e2b2e73a8c14ba01e0c6419ab523a3d77be33390e2cbc4","barcode_go0032465.png":"sha256:f4014ee6ed39d27d53d38969f289a46cbc4ff066c6031dd37d6bd118f9464117","barcode_lim_mammary_stem_cell.png":"sha256:135d7b3632d541fe2c79a42735b21983676c51a54f3589bf25ceea776692d9c6"},"comparison":{"stage":"pathway_enrichment","label":"Pathway analysis (GO, KEGG, fry, camera)","source":"The paper prints the fifteen leading over-represented GO terms, the fry gene set test of the three GO terms it selected, and the leading gene sets of the camera test over the mouse MSigDB C2 v5p1 collection.","criteria":[{"name":"go_over_representation","statement":"The GO terms over-represented among the differentially expressed genes are the same terms, with the same number of genes in each term, the same number of genes up and down in each term, and the same probabilities for each direction.","comparison":"the counts exactly, the probabilities to the three significant figures the paper prints","published":[{"term":"GO:0022402","ontology":"BP","size":931,"up":19,"down":118,"p_up":0.913,"p_down":2.69e-23},{"term":"GO:0000280","ontology":"BP","size":460,"up":10,"down":78,"p_up":0.789,"p_down":3.58e-23},{"term":"GO:1903047","ontology":"BP","size":628,"up":8,"down":92,"p_up":0.995,"p_down":1.56e-22},{"term":"GO:0048285","ontology":"BP","size":500,"up":11,"down":78,"p_up":0.785,"p_down":7.35e-21},{"term":"GO:0007067","ontology":"BP","size":376,"up":4,"down":66,"p_up":0.991,"p_down":1.51e-20},{"term":"GO:0007049","ontology":"BP","size":1301,"up":21,"down":138,"p_up":0.997,"p_down":6.22e-20},{"term":"GO:0000278","ontology":"BP","size":736,"up":8,"down":96,"p_up":0.999,"p_down":7.97e-20},{"term":"GO:0007059","ontology":"BP","size":237,"up":1,"down":49,"p_up":0.998,"p_down":1.5e-18},{"term":"GO:0051301","ontology":"BP","size":550,"up":6,"down":77,"p_up":0.997,"p_down":8.95e-18},{"term":"GO:0000776","ontology":"CC","size":112,"up":1,"down":33,"p_up":0.952,"p_down":8.99e-18},{"term":"GO:0000775","ontology":"CC","size":163,"up":1,"down":38,"p_up":0.988,"p_down":1.77e-16},{"term":"GO:0098813","ontology":"BP","size":171,"up":1,"down":38,"p_up":0.99,"p_down":9.64e-16},{"term":"GO:0042254","ontology":"BP","size":223,"up":1,"down":42,"p_up":0.998,"p_down":1.43e-14},{"term":"GO:0098687","ontology":"CC","size":278,"up":6,"down":47,"p_up":0.756,"p_down":2.69e-14},{"term":"GO:0005730","ontology":"CC","size":663,"up":4,"down":78,"p_up":1,"p_down":9.72e-14}],"verdict":"reproduced","agreements":["GO:0022402","GO:0000280","GO:1903047","GO:0048285","GO:0007067","GO:0007049","GO:0000278","GO:0007059","GO:0051301","GO:0000776","GO:0000775","GO:0098813","GO:0042254","GO:0098687","GO:0005730"],"differences":[],"compared":15,"detail":"15 of 15 agree with the paper"},{"name":"fry_gene_set_test","statement":"The gene set test of the three selected GO terms gives the same number of genes in each set, the same direction, and the same probabilities.","comparison":"the counts and directions exactly, the probabilities to the significant figures the paper prints","published":[{"gene_set":"GO:0032465","n_genes":48,"direction":"Up","p_value":0.000464,"fdr":0.00139},{"gene_set":"GO:0000920","n_genes":16,"direction":"Down","p_value":0.001902,"fdr":0.00285},{"gene_set":"GO:0000281","n_genes":30,"direction":"Up","p_value":0.007277,"fdr":0.00728}],"verdict":"reproduced","agreements":["GO:0032465","GO:0000920","GO:0000281"],"differences":[],"compared":3,"detail":"3 of 3 agree with the paper"},{"name":"camera_gene_set_test","statement":"The gene set test over the mouse MSigDB C2 v5p1 collection gives the same leading gene sets, with the same number of genes and the same direction, for the basal virgin against luminal virgin comparison.","comparison":"the counts and directions exactly, the probabilities to the two significant figures the paper prints","published":[{"gene_set":"LIM_MAMMARY_STEM_CELL_UP","n_genes":782,"direction":"Up","p_value":2.0e-43},{"gene_set":"LIM_MAMMARY_LUMINAL_MATURE_DN","n_genes":169,"direction":"Up","p_value":3.7e-25},{"gene_set":"SASAI_RESISTANCE_TO_NEOPLASTIC_TRANSFROMATION","n_genes":80,"direction":"Up","p_value":4.1e-20},{"gene_set":"LIM_MAMMARY_STEM_CELL_DN","n_genes":664,"direction":"Down","p_value":2.2e-19},{"gene_set":"FARMER_BREAST_CANCER_CLUSTER_4","n_genes":74,"direction":"Up","p_value":2.9e-19},{"gene_set":"NABA_BASEMENT_MEMBRANES","n_genes":52,"direction":"Up","p_value":1.6e-17},{"gene_set":"HAEGERSTRAND_RESPONSE_TO_IMATINIB","n_genes":35,"direction":"Up","p_value":4.0e-17},{"gene_set":"ROZANOV_MMP14_TARGETS_SUBSET","n_genes":83,"direction":"Up","p_value":5.2e-16},{"gene_set":"REACTOME_COLLAGEN_FORMATION","n_genes":70,"direction":"Up","p_value":1.3e-15},{"gene_set":"REACTOME_NCAM1_INTERACTIONS","n_genes":71,"direction":"Up","p_value":2.2e-15},{"gene_set":"OXFORD_RALB_TARGETS_UP","n_genes":27,"direction":"Up","p_value":4.5e-15},{"gene_set":"ANASTASSIOU_CANCER_MESENCHYMAL_TRANSITION_SIGNATURE","n_genes":148,"direction":"Up","p_value":7.1e-15}],"verdict":"reproduced","agreements":["LIM_MAMMARY_STEM_CELL_UP","LIM_MAMMARY_LUMINAL_MATURE_DN","SASAI_RESISTANCE_TO_NEOPLASTIC_TRANSFROMATION","LIM_MAMMARY_STEM_CELL_DN","FARMER_BREAST_CANCER_CLUSTER_4","NABA_BASEMENT_MEMBRANES","HAEGERSTRAND_RESPONSE_TO_IMATINIB","ROZANOV_MMP14_TARGETS_SUBSET","REACTOME_COLLAGEN_FORMATION","REACTOME_NCAM1_INTERACTIONS","OXFORD_RALB_TARGETS_UP","ANASTASSIOU_CANCER_MESENCHYMAL_TRANSITION_SIGNATURE"],"differences":[],"compared":12,"detail":"12 of 12 agree with the paper"},{"name":"go0032465_direction","statement":"GO:0032465 is enriched among the genes that are higher in the basal virgin group than in the basal lactating group.","comparison":"exact on the direction","published":{"term":"GO:0032465","direction":"up in B.virgin against B.lactating"},"verdict":"reproduced","agreements":["GO:0032465"],"differences":[],"compared":1,"detail":"1 of 1 agree with the paper"},{"name":"lim_mammary_stem_cell_direction","statement":"The LIM_MAMMARY_STEM_CELL signature is higher in the basal virgin group than in the luminal virgin group.","comparison":"exact on the direction","published":{"set":"LIM_MAMMARY_STEM_CELL","direction":"up in B.virgin against L.virgin"},"verdict":"reproduced","agreements":["the signature"],"differences":[],"compared":1,"detail":"1 of 1 agree with the paper"},{"name":"kegg_not_comparable","statement":"KEGG is a curated database that changes, so the KEGG numbers a run produces today cannot be compared with the ones the paper printed in 2016.","comparison":"not scored; the stage is reported and the reason it is not scored is given","published":"not comparable across time","verdict":"not scored","agreements":[],"differences":[],"compared":0,"observed":[{"pathway":"mmu04110","size":153,"up":1,"down":29,"p_up":0.591836515,"p_down":3.016301622e-27},{"pathway":"mmu03008","size":75,"up":0,"down":19,"p_up":1,"p_down":7.666597975e-21},{"pathway":"mmu01100","size":1330,"up":37,"down":57,"p_up":1.750292706e-15,"p_down":2.020355469e-18},{"pathway":"mmu04382","size":138,"up":13,"down":10,"p_up":1.803710868e-12,"p_down":3.610453469e-6},{"pathway":"mmu05150","size":47,"up":3,"down":11,"p_up":0.002611445354,"p_down":3.3938957e-12},{"pathway":"mmu05200","size":453,"up":11,"down":26,"p_up":7.658383128e-5,"p_down":1.202759745e-11},{"pathway":"mmu05166","size":214,"up":4,"down":18,"p_up":0.03692061608,"p_down":4.105916087e-11},{"pathway":"mmu05171","size":216,"up":4,"down":18,"p_up":0.03799544864,"p_down":4.791112757e-11},{"pathway":"mmu01232","size":76,"up":1,"down":12,"p_up":0.3588942391,"p_down":4.925622091e-11},{"pathway":"mmu04514","size":120,"up":2,"down":14,"p_up":0.154958117,"p_down":8.018907688e-11},{"pathway":"mmu04510","size":190,"up":13,"down":9,"p_up":1.043935465e-10,"p_down":0.0002986874179},{"pathway":"mmu04820","size":196,"up":13,"down":13,"p_up":1.537390259e-10,"p_down":3.502924311e-7},{"pathway":"mmu04972","size":69,"up":9,"down":4,"p_up":2.65411064e-10,"p_down":0.007402066459},{"pathway":"mmu04081","size":135,"up":11,"down":8,"p_up":4.621476803e-10,"p_down":0.0001417491619},{"pathway":"mmu04640","size":60,"up":2,"down":10,"p_up":0.04792712899,"p_down":1.18538522e-9}],"detail":"KEGG's content is versioned by the day, so the KEGG numbers this run produced cannot be compared with the ones the paper printed in May 2016."}],"summary":{"reproduced":5,"not_reproduced":0,"not_scored":1}},"log_sha256":"sha256:2984aeb7fe128cff29d10ffe3b64b94b6ecc8c1d801044e5eed7bb6508297db7","started_at":"2026-11-03T17:43:58.628105Z","completed_at":"2026-11-03T17:45:07.820185Z"},"integrity":{"dataset_sha256":"sha256:46cd415ac9b82853efb608bddc98cddbf8c7a908807877d448d9c73419b615cc","result_sha256":"sha256:6daad652773fe321cd885609fcc97c1378b769fa9173daaf172c33582fb30efb","bundle_hash":"d1d756c2c34777bc09aa0d236928ddd951666073cec97e52acd028342d3ed85f"},"replay_contract":{"description":"Re-running the operation on the dataset identified above must reproduce the recorded result hash exactly.","dataset_asset_id":"GEO:GSE60450:Lactation-GenewiseCounts","dataset_source_url":"https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/query/acc.cgi?acc=GSE60450","expected_dataset_sha256":"sha256:46cd415ac9b82853efb608bddc98cddbf8c7a908807877d448d9c73419b615cc","expected_result_sha256":"sha256:6daad652773fe321cd885609fcc97c1378b769fa9173daaf172c33582fb30efb","operation":"rna_seq_pathway_enrichment","operation_version":"0.1.0","design":{"paper":"pmid:27508061","paper_version":"2","stage":"pathway_enrichment","source_files":{"targets.txt":"sha256:88ae42c0539403073f0bbbd53287dd9c9cf61ddd5b1a42856243d7d99113cb8b","edgeRQL.R":"sha256:3b11478ac314c4456af8b4ba7af7992e938488ffc7bec88d3f73f42aed4c0bba","edgeRQL.Rnw":"sha256:defd3acb73dcbfe885ca02209ac9437b785b4ccf12c7ba09a8a8bb311173902d"},"software":{"edgeR":"3.14.0","limma":"3.28.21","org.Mm.eg.db":"3.3.0","GO.db":"3.3.0","gplots":"3.0.1"},"deviations":{"kegg_transport":"KEGG's REST endpoint now redirects http to https, and the pinned R's url() reader cannot follow a redirect, so the gene-to-pathway table kegga reads is fetched over https and passed to limma::kegga as the gene.pathway and pathway.names arguments that limma documents for supplying those tables directly. The species argument, the gene sets and the analysis are the authors' own.","r_patch_release":"The paper ran on R 3.3.1 and this platform runs on R 3.3.2.","limma_patch_release":"The paper ran on limma 3.28.6 and this platform runs on limma 3.28.21, the last patch of the same Bioconductor 3.3 series.","annotation_dbi_patch_release":"The paper ran on AnnotationDbi 1.34.3 and this platform runs on AnnotationDbi 1.38.0, the last patch of the same Bioconductor 3.3 series.","operating_system":"The paper ran on Windows 7 x64 and this platform runs on Linux."}},"platform":{"accession":null,"source_url":null,"sha256":null}}}